A newsletter for people committed to raising kind, competent children in the digital age.
Is listening the same as reading?
|
Hi Reader, Last month my extended family spent two weeks in Sicily celebrating my dad's 75th birthday. The food, the views, the weather — all incredible. But the real gift was something simpler: two uninterrupted weeks together. We spent hours driving between towns in a packed van, with all the cousins (ages 3–12) piled in with us. A handful of podcasts (Magical Storybook, Story Shed, Circle Round, But Why?) held all five rapt at once. It got me wondering: does listening "count" the same as reading? Turns out, mostly yes. A UC Berkeley study mapped how the brain processes meaning and found the maps for reading and listening to the same story were nearly identical. A 2022 meta-analysis of 46 studies and almost 4,700 people found no reliable comprehension gap between the two (only a slight advantage for reading when it comes to inferencing over literal comprehension). The exception is little kids. A Cincinnati Children's study found audio-only stories ran "too cold" for preschoolers, while an illustrated book read aloud hit the "just right" spot. So those podcasts probably weren't quite the same for my 3-year-old as a book on my lap — but it's nowhere near "not really reading" either. As always: somewhere in between. If you want to talk to your kids about this research and what they prefer (listening or reading), try these conversation starters: Ages 6–10: "What's your favorite podcast or audiobook right now? What makes it as good as a book?" Ages 11–13: "Do you think your brain works the same way whether you're reading a book or listening to one? What do you think scientists found?" Ages 13–16: "You know how people act like listening to an audiobook doesn't 'count' the same as reading? Turns out the science says otherwise — the brain processes it almost identically. Does that match how it feels for you?" And now, your turn. Hit reply and let me know - do you prefer reading books or listening to audiobooks? Do you find a difference in how you comprehend or process the information? In partnership, Dr. Rupa PS: Tech Ready - my digital driver's ed course for tweens and their parents - is here when you're ready! |
Tech Positive Parenting
A newsletter for people committed to raising kind, competent children in the digital age.
Hi Reader, I read a poem on Substack a few months back called “Please Use AI” by Shawn Smucker, and it hasn’t let go of me. Weeks later, it still pops into my head almost daily. My husband’s a technophile, an early adopter who uses AI for everything. I use it daily too, but with more hesitation. I read him the poem expecting him to be as floored as I was. He wasn’t. He argued people have always resisted new technology, and the truth is somewhere in the middle. He’s not wrong. But what stays...
Hi Reader, Growing up, the TV was on a lot at my house. Good Morning America hummed along every morning while my mom got us out the door. When my dad came home from work, the evening news turned on. I never thought twice about it because this was the case at most of my friends' houses too. At that time, the TV was one of the primary ways (alongside newspapers) that adults stayed connected to the world. My house now is almost the complete opposite. The TV is only on when someone is actively...
Hi Reader, Summer is in full swing here. Pool days, grilled everything, and later bedtimes. I’m relishing all of it. Growing up in Florida, summer afternoons meant movies. Thunderstorms and brutal heat drove us to the local AMC almost every week for the latest blockbuster. Settling into a cold theater with my friends is one of my favorite childhood memories. That nostalgia hit hard this past weekend when we took my girls to see Toy Story 5. It was my 3-year old's first movie in a theater....